Rejected Logomark: You Can't Always Get It Right the First Time...
I was so excited to get creative with this project. The client is in the wedding industry (a wedding officiant company), where every logo has rings or hearts and you can’t differentiate one from the next.

So, being a strategic brand designer, I wanted to puzzle out how to make them look different, while still keeping aligned with the industry (so people don’t look at the logo and go “huh?”).
As I chatted more with the client, I learned that their organization is all-inclusive. They have a massive roster of officiants, across all religions, as well as many non-religious ones, those who can do very formal ceremonies, all the way to super relaxed and informal ones.
So the logo & brand had to fit a wide range of options and still come across as welcoming and elegant no matter what kind of ceremony the couple was interested in.
I did a bunch of research and brainstorming on imagery that feels like a wedding & officiant, but isn’t as mainstream, and could still fit with all the types of ceremonies they do.
Things like flowers, aisles, arches, an infinity symbol, holding hands, a microphone, the silhouettes of 3 people, and a bunch more concepts.

Then I hit it: the book.
Every wedding officiant, no matter how fancy or casual, religious or not, has a book or binder or something that they reference as they lead the ceremony.
This fit the uniqueness quota, as other wedding officiant companies and competitors didn’t have anything similar.
However, just the book felt a little too vague. Like it could work for a library, or stationary shop, or probably lots of other businesses.
Now this isn’t always a problem in my opinion; a good logo isn’t intended to completely tell the viewer “here’s exactly what we do and who we serve” (that is more up to marketing messaging, helped by the brand identity as a whole). There are some really great logos out in the world that are so abstract they could work for a lot of industries, but all the other supporting factors and design features make it clear what they do.
BUT with that all considered, I still felt something was missing. We had wanted the brand to come across as elegant, welcoming, and warm, and with just the book, that warmth wasn’t there.
So I brought in one of the other concepts: flowers.
Maybe a wedding cliche, but when combined with the uniqueness of the book, this concept landed the perfect balance between differentiated and still fitting in with the industry.
I tried a ton of different ways to combine them, and researched a bunch of different flower options as well.


Did you know every flower has a different meaning? Roses signify love, freesias signify trust.. There were a lot of options.
However, I landed on the dalia, which signifies elegance. It’s a beautiful flower with lots of interconnectedness and complexities in the petals, which I felt perfectly emulated the many ways one can do a wedding, but all of it comes together.
Using the dalia like a bookmark in the officiant’s book felt like the perfect way to combine these elements. It almost feels like a little romantic gesture - leaving a single flower on your partner’s book for them to find later.

Now, as the title says, this option was rejected.
Once they saw the idea, while they loved the angle and creativity, the client realized that they did want to be ever so slightly more aligned with the industry. They viewed this logo as something great for the future, but wanted to be a little more safe right now.
Which is completely fine by me. I adore the opportunity to take a client out of their comfort zone and find a unique way to make them stand out, BUT I also completely respect that that isn’t always something that they may be ready for.
So, we ended up revisiting the idea and instead incorporated a ribbon-style heart to tie the company name together. This fits well within the industry, but the ribbon feel and connectedness of the logo as a whole was still set apart from the industry’s top cliches, so we all felt comfortable and happy with this direction.

This was an awesome project to be a part of, and a good reminder for me that the first idea isn't always going to be THE ONE.
My goal with logo & branding projects is always to help clients differentiate themselves from the competition, build trust with their customers, but also find something that truly FEELS like their company ethos visualized. I'm happy we were able to hit all 3 of those in this project, just took an extra step to get there :)



Comments